Mexican Martyrs: Another Mormon Myth Bites the Dust

I have had a vague memory of seeing a cheesy church-produced film in my youth involving two Mexican men who were executed by Emiliano Zapata’s guerrillas during the Mexican Revolution.

According to the film, these men were killed because they refused to renounce their Mormon faith. Here is the account as told in the current Book of Mormon teacher resource manual:

“A neighbor of the Monroys, fiercely opposed to their religious activities, went to the Zapata headquarters and denounced Rafael as a Carranzista and as a Mormon.

“Soldiers surrounded the Monroy house. Rafael was arrested together with Vicente, a member of the Church who happened to be visiting there. ‘Give up your arms,’ the soldiers demanded.

“Drawing from his pocket a Bible and a Book of Mormon, Rafael answered, ‘Senores, there are the only arms I ever carry. They are the arms of truth against error.’

“The two men were tortured, threatened and told to renounce their religion. ‘My religion is dearer to me than my life and I cannot forsake it,’ Rafael declared.

“He spent the afternoon in jail reading and explaining the scriptures to his fellow prisoners and to the guards. At 7 p.m. his mother brought some food. Rafael blessed it, but did not eat. ‘I am fasting today,’ he said.

“Moments later he and Vicente were marched to a large tree on the outskirts of San Marcos. They were offered their freedom if they would forsake their religion and join the Zapatistas. They refused.

“Rafael was allowed to pray. He knelt, and asked protection for his family, for the little branch. Finally, he prayed for his executioners, ‘Father, forgive them for they know not what they do.’

“Rising and folding his arms, he announced, ‘Senores, I am at your service.’

“‘Never have I seen men die more courageously,’ the soldier said” (“Two Members Died Courageously for the Truth,” Church News, 12 Sept. 1959, 19).

As a boy I was deeply impressed by this story of faith. Truly these men were martyrs for the cause.

The problem is that it’s not true. According to an article by Mark Grover of BYU, the men were killed because they had been accused of being supporters of Venustiano Carranza, Zapata’s enemy, and of having a hidden cache of weapons. Further, they were known to have associated with American missionaries and businessmen, which made them suspect to the Carranzistas.

Their religion was involved only tangentially. According to Monroy’s mother:

“As the days pass we are finding out little by little that also in this town there were false witnesses that helped to condemn to death my son saying that he perverted the people and taught a kind of religion and that he was a mormon and that word that they had not before heard they interpreted as some very bad thing and hatred and ill will follow us with the stories.”

The Zapatistas had never heard of Mormons, making it unlikely that the men were told to deny their faith; and there were no witnesses to the execution other than the Zapatistas, who didn’t mention anything about renouncing faith.

So, where did this incredibly faith-promoting story come from? It was related by mission president Rey Pratt, who seems to have laid things on more thickly with each telling.

It drives me crazy that, every time I dig into these faith-promoting stories, they turn out to be completely bogus. Brigham Young transfigured into Joseph Smith? Nope. Seagull miracle? Nope. Mexican martyrs? Nope.


8 Responses to Mexican Martyrs: Another Mormon Myth Bites the Dust

  1. I remember feeling really hurt when I discovered the stories the GA’s told were all crap. Really opened my eyes to the hyperbole. But then again, it made it a lot easier to start dismissing most of what they said as bogus.

  2. Sara Kenyon says:

    What is your source for the truth on the miracle of the seagulls? This is the first I’ve heard of that.

    • runtu says:

      Here’s a good discussion from William Hartley:

      The point is that, despite the mythology that has been built up, the seagulls didn’t do much to slow down the crickets, and there was nothing miraculous about the episode. This would explain why nobody mentions them in contemporary journals.

  3. What are the stories behind the supposed transfiguration of Brigham to Joseph and the seagull miracle? Do you have blogs on those stories as well?

  4. […] Postal Service? Also noted about the CoJCoL-dS: Runtu’s once-favorite faith-promoting tale is false, but fortunately another Mormon has found new proof of the gospel. Ben is filling in the details of […]

  5. Daniel says:

    Milk strippings? Nope.

    Great snakes, did they lie about everything?!

  6. Bradley Hill says:

    The film to which you refer appears to have incorporated two then-popular “legends” about the Church during the Mexican Revolution. I, too, note that poetic license prevailed over historic accuracy in this production. My personal testimony of the restoration remains strong, and I also feel strongly about the pursuit of truth. You may be interested in reading F. Lamont Tullis’s new book “Martyrs in Mexico: A Mormon Story of Revolution and Redemption”, which will be released in the middle of May 2018.

    In the interest of full disclosure, I had the opportunity to assist in a small way with the editing of this book, but have no financial connection with it or its author.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: